The Punisher

The Punisher 2004

I’ve been a fan of this movie ever since it came out, I’m not sure if I saw it in theaters, but if I didn’t, then I saw it shortly afterwards. I have yet to see the extended edition of this movie but I would really like to sometime. Extended editions aren’t always improvements to the movie, I know several times that I watched the extended edition of a movie without realizing it, and I know in the case of Superman: The Movie, it felt like it was too drawn out and I think I would have preferred watching the theatrical version rather than the extended edition. But other times, movies get cut down for other reasons and the extended edition is actually the preferred version, like in the case of Daredevil. But since I already own the regular version of this DVD, I went ahead and watched it tonight instead of watching The Spirit that we rented last night so I could finish up the non-trilogy of Punisher movies. There were a few scenes that I didn’t care for as much as I did when I first watched the movie, but I still enjoyed it a ton more than either of the other Punisher movies I’ve watched this week.

Of the three movies, this is the only one that actually covers Frank Castle’s origin and gets it wrong. In both of the other movies, they stick closer to the comics origin as I understand it. In the comics, Frank and his wife and children witness a mob hit. In retaliation, the mob kills him and his family and yet Frank manages to survive and becomes The Punisher to enact punishment to the mob that killed his family and escaped the law. In this movie, Frank is a deep undercover agent on his last sting operation to take down an arms smuggler. Things go bad for one person who ends up dead. Unfortunately, that person was the son of Howard Saint, and Saint’s wife wants revenge on Frank’s entire family. Not just his wife and kids, but his entire extended family who are with him in Puerto Rico for a reunion to celebrate his retirement. As with the other origins, Frank is left for dead but ends up surviving. It was kind of interesting to see a bit of his life before becoming The Punisher, but because it’s such a small part of the movie, his family doesn’t really get enough development. He does get some cool points for having Rob Sheider as his dad. While I did enjoy the action scene at the reunion, I think it works better when his family is already just a memory.

It always amazes me how tiny Thomas Jane looks next to Kevin Nash.

From there, it moves on to the heart of the story, the revenge plot to punish Howard Saint. As I mentioned in my review for War Zone, I really enjoy well done revenge plots and this one is no exception. Through all the stages of the plot, it shows Frank as an intelligent and resourceful man rather than just an arsenal of weaponry. I also really liked how the movie set up how he created a lot of his gadgets himself, rather than just having a stock full of weapons and a bulletproof vest. I also liked the inside man, he was a fun character. But of course, the story doesn’t entirely revolve around just his revenge plot, there’s also the side stories of the two hitmen hired by Saint to kill Frank once again after he finds out that Frank wasn’t quite dead yet. Both of the scenes are fairly short and I enjoyed both of them, even if the fight with the Russian is played up mostly as a humorous fight scene even if it’s the one where Frank comes off the worse for wear.

The biggest problem that most people have with this movie are the neighbors in Frank’s building. There’s John Pinette which I’m familiar with for his stand up routine “You go now! You here four howa!” and is playing the funny fat guy, Ben Foster who would later go on to play Angel in X-Men plays the downtrodden pierced gamer guy who sees Frank stick up for him once and claims that he’s family enough to endure the torture of having his piercings ripped off of his face one by one. And there’s Joan, played by Rebecca Romijn Stamos who was also in X-men, who is the token love interest. I thought the two guys were somewhat funny for the most part and I liked them ok, their half of the scene with the Russian was rather annoying, and there wasn’t really any chemistry between Joan and Frank, though I am glad that they respected the character enough that he knew she was a bad idea, but I’m disappointed that they made it seem like he thought about it. I thought they worked well when they were just the funny neighbors with problems, I didn’t like it so much when they became integrated into the plot as much as they were.

These two are definitely NOT like Bulk and Skull. Don't ask me why I brought that up.

The villains in this movie were all fairly interesting as well, aside from the rather pointless son who I don’t even remember his name. He just basically stands there and says next to nothing the entire movie. I enjoyed John Travolta as Howard Saint as he played the calculating mob boss during the first part of the movie and gradually descended into a panic as his world comes crumbling down around him while Frank survives hit after hit. Quentin as his right hand man and closeted gay mobster was played very well, as someone with several gay friends, it’s nice to see a gay character portrayed as someone who’s not a flaming queen. Saint’s wife is also a nice character as someone who loves her family and yet is also a cold mobster when it comes right down to it.

The violence in this movie I felt hit the right balance, there is some pretty graphic violence with some of the kills, and yet there are almost as many that are practically bloodless. I enjoyed this style much better than the War Zone version where every single death had to be an extreme gore-fest. There’s also a couple other minor parts of the movie that I really enjoyed and have to mention, the animation during the opening credits is really simple and yet well done and amazing to look at, and the first hitman sings a funeral song to Frank before attacking him, and I just really enjoy hearing that little song. It may seem out of place, but somehow it just works for me. And while I do admit that this isn’t the best version of The Punisher that there could be, but for my money I really enjoy watching it, and unless you’re a big fan of how The Punisher is in the comics, I imagine most people would enjoy it too. Until next time, this has been Bubbawheat for Flights, Tights, and Movie Nights.


About Bubbawheat

I'm a comic book movie enthusiast who has watched and reviewed over 500 superhero and comic book movies in the past seven years, my goal is to continue to find and watch and review every superhero movie ever made.

Posted on April 5, 2012, in 00's movies, Marvel and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. Reverend Moonshine


    My younger brother and I grew up being big comic book fans, so we often debate about our opinions regarding recent comic book movies.

    My take on movies that come from books (especially comic books) is that the director has a choice of being faithful to the source material or making a good movie. People who try to do both usually fail to do either, and comparing this movie to War Zone is the perfect example. This movie abandoned the source material for the sake of making a good movie, while War Zone was faithful to the source material, which made it a bad movie. Punisher comic book fans will prefer War Zone, while movie fans who aren’t familiar with the source material will like Thomas Jane’s portrayal better.

    Another good example of this concept is The Outsiders (1983) movie. The book was wonderful, but the original Outsiders movie left out many of the book’s story elements for the sake of time. Then, sometime about 10-15 years ago, the studio released a DVD titled “The Outsiders: The Complete Novel.” This new version of the movie was, in my opinion, a downgrade. They inserted a soundtrack that drowns out much of the dialogue (forcing me to turn on the English subtitles), and I didn’t think any of the restored footage added anything of value to the story; it just made the movie longer. A lot of people like the new “complete novel” version of the movie better than the 1983 theatrical version, but I’m not one of them.

    I wish movie directors would learn that a movie can’t be true to its source material and still be a good movie. The two media are too different. A book can delve into the smallest details, while a story in a movie needs to move along quickly. A comic book is only limited by its author’s and artist’s imaginations, but a movie has limits, even with the latest computer generated special effects.

    I think one reason I enjoy comic book movies more than my brother is that I don’t care about the source material, I just want to see a good movie. Do I care that other versions of Superman would find a way to win without killing General Zod? No. I want directors to have the freedom to take risks.

    Even if you claim to be faithful to the source material, which source material are you faithful to? The comic book version of Superman has been rebooted at least twice (or was it thrice?), and I find the differences between the different Supermen interesting. In some versions, John Kent dies when Superman is a teenager (like in the 1978 movie), but Martha Kent lives into old age. In the latest iteration of Superman in The New 52, Clark Kent was orphaned at a young age, inheriting his parents farm and hiring someone to run it when he goes off to college.

    • I mostly agree with your comment, but I do think there are rare instances where a filmmaker can stay true to the book and still make a good film. Constantine is another example of a good movie that is nothing like the comic that it’s based on. I never read the comic and I like the movie.

  1. Pingback: 100 Essential Superhero Movies | Flights, Tights, and Movie Nights

  2. Pingback: FTMN Quickie: Punisher Extended Cut | Flights, Tights, and Movie Nights

  3. Pingback: 100 Essential Superhero Movies: 2016 Edition | Flights, Tights, and Movie Nights

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: